Thursday, August 25, 2011

OPINION Revisiting Anna This movement has an energy that cannot be dismissed with labels like middle class, upper caste, right wing, or the most commonly used, "RSS plot". SABA NAQVI

OPINION
Revisiting Anna
This movement has an energy that cannot be dismissed with labels like middle class, upper caste, right wing, or the most commonly used, "RSS plot".
On April 10 after observing the Anna Hazare show at Jantar Mantar for three days I had written a piece, "The Jagran At Jantar Mantar". The overt Hindu symbolism of the movement, its middle class nature and manufactured television histrionics, had been analysed in that piece.

Since then the summer has gone and we are at the end of the monsoon season.

The movement has clearly evolved into something far bigger than anything any of us had anticipated. This week it became the biggest mass upsurge I have seen since the Ram janmaboomi movement. The Ram movement did not take place in the age of round the clock TV coverage and many of us saw the Babri mosque fall on BBC.

Now the power of the Anna crowd is magnified by the power of television. According to an MP who was part of JP's movement, this is bigger. However such comparisions may be unfair as the JP movement was sustained for two years in an altogether different age.

Yet the last few days at Ramlila maidan (where in the past I have attended numerous VHP and BJP rallies) have been an education. To see this as a middle class explosion would be a mistake as the working class is now dominating the show. In the humid monsoon heat, the Anna saga has become a lighting rod for discontent, an avenue to vent frustration, perhaps also celebrate and be part of a tamasha. The lumpen class is also there, enjoying the carnival atmosphere, trying to press their bodies against women who venture into the crushing mass of humanity at night as I did on Sunday when the crowds reached record numbers.

Unlike the committed but smaller crowds in sustained people's struggles many here do not know what they want but they do have a great frutration with the system. Currently this movement has an energy that cannot be dismissed with labels like middle class, upper caste, right wing, or the most commonly used, "RSS plot".
There is a point at which the middle class, upper caste and RSS do overlap and converge but that would now be just be one angle to the story. Vested interests and forces do try to take over or claim anything big as their own. The RSS and VHP have openly declared support for Anna Hazare and routinely send SMSs to journalists about their mobilisation. I have no doubt that they would love to take credit for this movement as all their other efforts in recent years have been a spectacular failure.
Suspicion of the "RSS hand" must not howver cloud our ability to see something new and unknown happening before our eyes. The organisers of the movement have consiously tried to tone down the symbolism that was visible at the Jantar mantar round of protest. The portrait of Bharat Mata under which Anna Hazare rests is now replaced by Mahatma Gandhi. And in every speech that I have heard Arvind Kejriwal make of late (the most effective public speaker of Team Anna) he has spoken of all communities joining in. He has evoked the token secularism of Muslims breaking their fast and Hindus celebrating Janmashthami together. A friend who attended on an afternoon sat through an hour of speeches made by a maulana and some ordinary Muslims.
These are strands in an evolving situation. Minorities too feel angry and frutrated and some do want to join what they see as a crusade against a corrupt system. Yet many are hesitant because they are unsure of what is happening and have been told that the movement could eventually be targetted against them. That is the sort of mentality that the Imam Bukhari of Delhi's Jama Masjid feeds into. Yet all the Muslims I have met and spoken to have been also been put off by the condemnation of this movement on communal lines. Members of the community do not always like to view everything through the prism of their religious identity. Like others, many Muslims too have landed up at Ramlila maidan as curious onlookers.
Many liberals who lean towards the left and are not embedded in the Congress patronage system, want to keep an open mind. Yet they wonder if the BJP is in the fortunate position of being the eventual political beneficiary of such a movement? Indian politics is too fragmented and scattered today for any definitive answers. Currently the crisis in the Congress has been accentuated and by default that can be seen as good news for the BJP. But in the long term this force that has been unleashed can present both an opportunity and a challenge to the BJP. This movement is not burdened by the sectarian agenda of the BJP/RSS yet it often uses an idiom and vocabulary that had worked for forces of the right in the past. The situation itherefore is too open ended for us to know what comes next.

Yesterday afternoon at Ramlila maidan there was a young man wearing a huge contraption on his head designed like a wedding cake. On the first level it was written "Inquilab Zindabad", on the second tier it was "Vande Mataram", on the third tier "I am Anna". I believe we should hesitate before pinning any ideological label or neat isms (fascism, casteism, communalism) on what is unfolding before our eyes.

TEXT SIZE   
PRINT
SHARE
COMMENTS
FILED IN: 
AUTHORS:  SABA NAQVI 
PEOPLE:  ANNA HAZARE 
TAGS:  LOKAYUKTA & LOKPAL | CORRUPTION | PROTESTS | RSS | BJP | RIGHT-WING | MIDDLE CLASS | CASTE 
SECTION:  NATIONAL 
SUBSECTION:  OPINION
TRANSLATE INTO:
Powered by Translate
 
DAILY MAIL
AUG 25, 2011 08:06 PM
7

 "I believe we should hesitate before pinning any ideological label or neat isms (fascism, casteism, communalism) on what is unfolding before our eyes."

It would be better if Saba keeps this advice in her desk and see it before she types her next article. She happens to be more communal than Bukhari himself. At least Bukhari has the honesty to say what he really feels. He does not hide his feelings behind pseudo secular phrases like Saba does.

Also the tone of article is condescending.

GANESAN
NJ, USA
AUG 25, 2011 07:58 PM
6

Subah ka bhula agar sham ko wapas aa jaye to usse bhula nahin kehte. Thank you Saba for your graciousness in acknowledging the shortcomings in your previous article. Much better than scores of fools who continue to peddle nonsensical and stupendous theories to deride this movement.

Welcome onboard!

AMIT
TUCSON, UNITED STATES
AUG 25, 2011 07:15 PM
5

Saba Naqvi

You are not too far away in trying to impart a communal hue to Anna Hazar's fast and anti-corruption crusade again, like what you did in your previous April article 'The Jagran at Jantar Mantar' where you plagiarised from George Orwell's 'Notes on Nationalism' in your support in order to deride those who have only the symbols and slogans [of our freedom struggle] to fight for their soul and pride. May I quote you:

"Such random thoughts [from Orwell] immediately came to my mind when I noted that the most popular slogan at the show was Vande Mataram. Only once did I hear the more secular Inquilab Zindabad. I have nothing against Vande Mataram ... Yet here we were in the year 2011 with youngsters screaming Vande Mataram with great passion."

Why journos like you are so intent reporting on critical issues in India's long term national intrerests such as the one raised by Anna Hazare and his team with a communal stigma. You yourself admit that Muslims have been mislead by elements like Imam Bukhari on the true intentions of movements like these, yet you are very apt in snatching any opportunity that comes your way to try and find a RSS/BJP hand in the glove syndrome in every agitation that seeks to challenge a Congress govt or its policies.

So, now you think that this time round Anna is more white than saffron just because the Mahatma has replaced the Bharat Mata on his podium. But has that changed his original call to the people of India to wake up and rise to fight the rampant corruption that has become an almost indelible part of our daily lives. 

And, while you wait and see what label you can attach to Anna's movement, let me tell you this that those people who are shouting Vande Matram, Inqilab Zindabad, Bharat Mata ki jai or singing 'Raghupait Raghav Rajaram ...ishwar allah tero nam' on the streets of Delhi and all over India, are no more "nationalist" than either me or you, and they don't for a moment think which one of these slogan is Hindu, Muslim, secular or communal. All they know that they are fed up with the daily corruption and apparent lack of any political will among the governing classes to address it. They just want to stand up together and face their masters head on, and tell them to do someting or get out ... these slogans are their Mantras that gives them  strength and courage as they did pre-1947, to Hindu, Muslim, Sikh alike ..

THE CONTRARIAN
LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
AUG 25, 2011 06:57 PM
4

Fundamentally (!) this woman is deeply communal.

This article, which is a little less focussed on providing cover to the Jihadis, is an intersesting but almost certainly a very brief diversion.

Just wait fir the next article.

PRADIP SINGH
STAFFORD, UNITED KINGDOM
AUG 25, 2011 06:38 PM
3

At last,  Allah the Merciful,  seems to have blessed you to come out of your communal angle. At least for now.

But how were  "Vande maataram and Bharat Maata Ki Jai " Hindu symbols ? Once they are removed  from Anna's platform,  his movement is  Ok with you ? Admit it gracefully that you were wrong in castigating Anna's movement in April.

Communal  Leaders like Bukhari are short sighted enough and take  Indian Muslims up the garden path. The result is that Muslims end up getting alienated from the mainstream.

G. NIRANJAN RAO
HYDERABAD, ANDHRA PRADESH, INDIA
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
at

No comments:

Post a Comment